Rajeev Masand

type your search and hit enter

Our Films

Flirting at forty

 
 

Shirin Farhad Ki Toh Nikal Padi

Rating: 3

August 24, 2012

Cast: Boman Irani, Farah Khan, Daisy Irani, Shammi, Mahabanoo Mody-Kotwal

Director: Bela Bhansali Sehgal

Unwilling to settle for the first girl who’s paraded before him, 45-year-old bachelor Farhad Pastakia is clear he will marry only for love. Farhad, played by a terrific Boman Irani in debutant director Bela Bhansali Sehgal’s Shirin Farhad Ki Toh Nikal Padi, is a lingerie salesman at a nearby store, and lives with his widowed mum (Daisy Irani) and her mother (yesteryear actress Shammi) in a Parsi colony in Mumbai. While his job proves to be a hurdle when it comes to his eligibility in the marriage market, his mum presents herself as an obstacle when Farhad finally meets his soulmate in feisty spinster Shirin Fuggawala, played with considerable zest by choreographer-filmmaker Farah Khan.

Romantic without ever being sickeningly sweet, and witty without wallowing in crude toilet humor, Shirin Farhad works on account of its inherent sincerity, and because Bela tells a simple story with simplicity. The film’s basic premise – of a romance thwarted by parental opposition – is hardly original, but writer Sanjay Leela Bhansali (Bela’s brother) puts a fresh spin on that familiar formula by weaving the love story around a middle-aged couple.

Setting it against the backdrop of the Parsi community gives the film a distinct texture, and much of Shirin Farhad’s light-hearted laughs come from the quirkiness of its characters. Like the delusional old neighbor who’s in an imaginary relationship with Indira Gandhi, or Farhad’s own mother who clings on with dear life to an illegal water tank that her husband installed in their home before his death. It helps that Bela casts real Parsis in all speaking roles (Daisy Irani, Shammi, and Mahabanoo Modi-Kotwal as Shirin’s doting aunt, are the pick of the lot); that gives the film an authentic flavor instead of the fake impressions that non-Parsi actors invariably deliver in Parsi roles.

At the heart of the film, of course, are Boman Irani and Farah Khan who are superbly cast and bring so much to their characters by way of accents and mannerisms and evidently improvised dialogue. On looking at the steeply-priced dishes on a menu while out on a date, Shirin asks Farhad: “Bartan toh nahin dhona padega na?

The couple shares a warm chemistry, and some of the most enjoyable moments in the film involve their peculiar responses to such romantic-movie staples as the first kiss, the hint of sexual attraction, and the marriage proposal. When she’s in hospital for accidentally swallowing a cherry that contained the ring Farhad was going to propose with, Shirin tells him: “Maine kabhi nahin socha tha meri shaadi ka ring yahan se niklega!

Not everything works though. Even if you’re willing to look beyond the TV serial-production values, it’s hard to overlook the fact that Shirin Farhad succumbs to loud melodrama occasionally, and some bits stand out for sheer silliness. A portion towards the end, where Farhad is bashed up by neighbors and hauled to the police station for attempting to climb over a gate, feels pointless. And it doesn’t help that the film’s narrative is punctured by too many songs that serve no real purpose other than adding to the film’s length.

It’s a good thing the film’s merits far outnumber its flaws. Beneath its cheeky wit and some of those slapstick gags, Shirin Farhad subtly touches upon issues like pride in one’s profession, embracing one’s physicality, and no expiry date on love. Bela steers clear of caricaturing the Parsi community, at best allowing Parsi characters themselves to take affectionate jibes at each others’ tics.

I’m going with three out of five for director Bela Bhansali Sehgal’s Shirin Farhad Ki Toh Nikal Padi. It’s a charming film made with heart. Give it a chance, you won’t be disappointed.

(This review first aired on CNN-IBN)

14 Responses to “Flirting at forty”

  1. CS says:

    Had read some opposing views on the film, but after reading your nice review, will go watch it.

  2. k says:

    I can’t believe you gave this movie same rating as Gangs of Wasseypur – 2!!! You need to improve your rating system!!!

  3. Delmer says:

    The movie is an average ,had expectations like kya super kool hai hum and made us laught on ur seats for a few minutes only ,a must entertainer ,is like a jenie in a lamp but with limited wishes my ratings will be 3 on 5 stars

  4. Ravi says:

    Pls dont narrate scenes from the movie. spoils the viewing experience!

  5. honest says:

    Rajeev we expect a honest reply from you…..This movie has nothing to watch and half star is more than enough.
    Dont imagine, you have given ek tha tiger 2.5 and this movie 3.
    We believe on you, dont rate the movie by the person you like.

  6. Veturi Sarma says:

    well that cherry in the ring scene was from Woody Allen’s Everyone Says I Love You

  7. With you giving 3 for Expendables, my hopes with this movie has ended…

  8. Farah Khan is inarguably the “most irritating actor”, audiences’ have had to endure in a long-long time….

    Movie has got nothing except for Boman Irani…

  9. Fardeen says:

    8 of us went to watch this movie @Rs:300/per person.Rajeev we demand a refund from you and not Farah.Farah dug us a grave you pushed us into it.

  10. Fab says:

    Love reading your reviews Rajeev, but wish you’d stop giving out spoilers!!

  11. Aman says:

    i saw it today … and your review is right about the film ….

  12. Sam says:

    This was ur worst review ever.we couldnt watch the movie till interval

  13. Parvinder says:

    Hi rajeev,
    I always trust your comments and found them close to my taste (or people with our taste). May be your comments are not liked by people with different taste. So please keep writing what pleaes you.
    Thanks.

  14. Tom says:

    OMG !
    3 stars… ?
    Pathethic… ! Used to look for your reviews on movies,but not anymore…

Leave a Reply